In public accounting, many Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) encounter a career plateau before advancing to managerial roles. This phenomenon, often referred to as the “CPA career plateau,” has significant implications for both individual professionals and the firms that employ them. Addressing these career bottlenecks is crucial for sustaining firm performance, improving talent retention, and enhancing career satisfaction. Structural issues within firms and overlooked promotion cues frequently contribute to this stagnation. Drawing on deep expertise in public accounting recruitment, this article examines the root causes of these plateaus and offers actionable strategies for firms and CPAs to overcome them.
Understanding the Public Accounting Career Ladder
The public accounting career path is typically structured, with well-defined stages. Entry-level CPAs begin as associates or staff accountants, progressing to senior associate roles as they gain technical proficiency and experience. Advancement to managerial positions requires not only technical expertise but also the development of client management and leadership skills.
Key milestones for promotion include mastery of complex accounting standards, successful client engagements, and demonstrated leadership potential. Industry certifications, such as the CPA license, are essential, but firms also expect professionals to cultivate soft skills and business acumen. Organizational hierarchies and staffing models play a pivotal role in shaping these career trajectories, influencing both the pace and nature of advancement.
Why Some CPAs Plateau Before Manager
Several factors contribute to the “public accounting career” plateau. A common bottleneck occurs when technical proficiency outpaces managerial skill development. Many CPAs excel in technical tasks but lack sufficient exposure to client-facing or team leadership responsibilities, which are prerequisites for promotion.
Internal factors, such as firm culture, also play a role. Resistance to change, limited mentorship, and inadequate training programs can hinder career progression. Externally, industry-wide challenges—high workloads, work-life balance concerns, and a competitive environment—further complicate advancement.
Psychologically, professionals may become comfortable with routine tasks, making it difficult to step outside their comfort zones. This sense of stagnation can diminish morale and reduce professional ambition, reinforcing the plateau.
The Role of Firm Structure and Culture in Career Stagnation
Firm organizational design significantly impacts promotion opportunities. Flat organizations may offer broader responsibilities but fewer formal advancement steps, while hierarchical structures can provide clearer promotion paths yet risk bottlenecking talent. Effective talent management practices are essential for preparing employees for leadership roles.
Cultural factors, such as communication gaps about career expectations or unclear performance metrics, can cause high-potential CPAs to miss promotion cues. Without transparent feedback and clearly defined career paths, employees may not recognize what is required for advancement.
A culture of continuous development—characterized by open feedback, transparent promotion criteria, and diverse training options—supports sustained career growth and reduces the risk of plateauing.
Recognizing and Addressing Missed Promotion Cues
Early identification of stagnation is critical. Warning signs include declining initiative, limited cross-functional exposure, and lack of engagement in new projects. Performance reviews and employee surveys can provide valuable feedback on these issues.
Tailored mentorship and coaching are powerful tools for addressing career bottlenecks. Managers play a crucial role in recognizing potential and offering structured guidance. Internal mentorship programs, complemented by external perspectives, can help CPAs develop the skills needed for promotion.
Proactive strategies—such as regular career check-ins, skills assessments, and leadership development programs—enable early intervention. Leveraging technology and HR analytics helps firms pinpoint promotion delays and address them systematically.
Strategic Recommendations for Firms
To break the cycle of “accounting promotion challenges,” firms should revamp talent management and development programs. Training initiatives focused on managerial competencies, combined with mentoring partnerships and cross-departmental collaboration, prepare CPAs for leadership roles.
Redesigning organizational structures to foster growth involves simplifying hierarchical layers and creating progressive roles that serve as stepping stones to management. Clear career roadmaps, shared with all employees, set expectations and motivate advancement.
Performance metrics and regular feedback are essential for identifying skill gaps and aligning career aspirations with firm needs. Diversity, inclusion, and innovation should be prioritized to bring varied perspectives into leadership and challenge traditional career paradigms.
The Role of Recruitment in Overcoming the Plateau
Recruitment experts play a pivotal role in bridging talent gaps within public accounting firms. Specialized recruiting, such as that provided by Kevin Chen Recruiting, identifies high-potential CPAs and matches them with firms seeking future leaders. These professionals offer strategic insights into talent market trends and career progression dynamics.
External recruitment expertise can drive internal transformation. For example, firms that have partnered with recruitment specialists often report improved promotion dynamics and a stronger leadership pipeline. Showcasing career success stories, through testimonials and data-driven results, enhances employer branding and inspires both current and prospective employees.
Case Studies and Real-World Examples
Several firms have successfully addressed CPA career plateaus by implementing targeted initiatives. For instance, one mid-sized firm overhauled its mentorship program, pairing senior leaders with high-potential CPAs and introducing quarterly leadership workshops. Within two years, the firm reported a 20% increase in internal promotions and a marked improvement in retention.
Another firm, after consulting with recruitment experts, redesigned its performance review system to include clear, actionable feedback and individualized development plans. This led to higher employee engagement and a more robust leadership pipeline.
These examples underscore the value of systematic change and external expertise in overcoming career bottlenecks. Insights from recruitment professionals have helped reshape firm structures and foster a culture of continuous development.
Sustaining Momentum in CPA Career Development
Addressing career plateaus in public accounting requires a multifaceted approach. Firms must recognize the interplay between structure, culture, and individual development, and implement strategies that promote continuous growth. Proactive talent management, transparent communication, and targeted recruitment are essential for building a resilient leadership pipeline. As industry demands evolve, adaptive strategies and a commitment to professional development will remain central to long-term success in public accounting careers.
References
- Malmgren, R. D., Ottino, J. M., & Amaral, L. A. N. (2010). The role of mentorship in protege performance. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/1006.2312
- Haegele, I. (2022). Talent hoarding in organizations. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.15098
- Costa, L. A., Dias, E., Ribeiro, D. M., Fontão, A., Pinto, G., Santos, R. P., & Serebrenik, A. (2024). An actionable framework for understanding and improving talent retention as a competitive advantage in IT organizations. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01573
- Roessner, B. (2023, September 30). Mentoring at CPA firms fosters strong leaders. AICPA & CIMA. https://www.aicpa-cima.com/resources/article/mentoring-at-cpa-firms-fosters-strong-leaders
- The Tax Adviser. (2023, September). A path to improving firms’ employee retention. The Tax Adviser. https://www.thetaxadviser.com/issues/2023/sep/a-path-to-improving-firms-employee-retention/
- LifthCM. (2025). Strategic talent management: Attracting, developing, and retaining. LifthCM. https://lifthcm.com/article/talent-management-attracting-developing-retaining
- NJCPA. (2024, January 3). Evolving accounting firm culture. NJCPA. https://www.njcpa.org/article/2024/01/03/evolving-accounting-firm-culture
- Canopy. (2023). The role of mentorship in accounting firms. Canopy. https://www.getcanopy.com/blog/the-role-of-mentorship-in-accounting-firms
- Weinstein Spira. (2023). Supporting employees on their CPA exam journey. Weinstein Spira. https://www.weinsteinspira.com/supporting-employees-on-their-cpa-exam-journey/
- TrustBGW. (2023, September). How can CPA firms attract and retain top accounting talent? TrustBGW. https://www.trustbgw.com/blog/how-can-cpa-firms-attract-and-retain-top-accounting-talent
- Journal of Accountancy. (2014, November). Making manager: The key to accelerating a career in public accounting. Journal of Accountancy. https://www.journalofaccountancy.com/issues/2014/nov/201410459/
- Journal of Accountancy. (2014, September). Avoid a career stall. Journal of Accountancy. https://www.journalofaccountancy.com/issues/2014/sep/cpa-careers-201410472/
- CPA Journal. (2025, April 11). Attracting and retaining top talent in accounting. CPA Journal. https://www.cpajournal.com/2025/04/11/attracting-and-retaining-top-talent-in-accounting/
- CPA Practice Advisor. (2025, April 14). How to build a robust pipeline of accounting talent for your CPA firm. CPA Practice Advisor. https://www.cpapracticeadvisor.com/2025/04/14/how-to-build-a-robust-pipeline-of-accounting-talent-for-your-cpa-firm/159075/
- Accounting Today. (2024, October). What’s behind the talent exodus in accounting? Accounting Today. https://www.accountingtoday.com/list/whats-behind-the-talent-exodus-in-accounting
- Thomson Reuters. (2024, February). Broken workload management, other issues blocking pipeline of CPA talent, study says. Thomson Reuters. https://tax.thomsonreuters.com/news/broken-workload-management-other-issues-blocking-pipeline-of-cpa-talent-study-says/
- IMA. (2023). Talent retention in the U.S. accounting and finance profession. Institute of Management Accountants (IMA). https://www.imanet.org/research-publications/ima-reports/talent-retention-in-the-us-accounting-and-finance-profession
- Software Oasis. (2025). Top 2025 entry-level accountant retention rates: Data charts. Software Oasis. https://softwareoasis.com/entry-level-accountant-retention-rates/
- Future Firm. (2025, February 14). Accountant shortage: What does it mean for your firm? Future Firm. https://futurefirm.co/accountant-shortage/
- CPA Journal. (2024, February 12). The conflict surrounding work-life balance in public accounting firms. CPA Journal. https://www.cpajournal.com/2024/02/12/the-conflict-surrounding-work-life-balance-in-public-accounting-firms/
- Journal of Accountancy. (2023, December 6). Expand the accounting pipeline with a mentorship circle. Journal of Accountancy. https://www.journalofaccountancy.com/newsletters/academic-update/expand-the-accounting-pipeline-with-a-mentorship-circle/
- Journal of Accountancy. (2020, October). Mentors pave career pathways. Journal of Accountancy. https://www.journalofaccountancy.com/newsletters/2020/oct/mentors-pave-career-pathways/
- ORCPA. (2025, January). Embracing a human-first culture: The key to the future of accounting. Oregon Society of CPAs (ORCPA). https://www.orcpa.org/news/7fcf58b0-7aae-4df2-b084-46d84c0ee282%3Aembracing-a-human-first-culture-the-key-to-the-future-of-accounting
- Sapro. (2024). The accounting skills shortage: Innovatively navigating the gap. Sapro. https://www.sapro.com/blog/the-accounting-skills-shortage-innovatively-navigating-the-gap
- Miles Education. (2024, July 25). 10 career paths for CPAs. Miles Education. https://www.mileseducation.com/accounting/blogs/7-career-paths-for-cpas